RA
RA Japan
Global
Local
Music
Interact
Search RA

The Feed


Dance music's creative crisis
Philip Sherburne looks into "the vicious circle that forces producers to DJ (and DJs to produce)" over at Spin.
http://www.spin.com/blogs/dance-musics-creative-crisis-its-not-just-st..
Words / terrencefuller
Published / Friday, 16 November 2012 04:03 AM
Comments / 19 Comments
Share this page

Comments

Dance music's creative crisis

You're not logged in. You need to register to
post your comments.

Anyone can register on RA. Even you.

thejaguarwrote
Sun, 18 Nov 2012Shed yes, Scuba and Dettmann are average. I mean seriously. Clearly Shed is head and shoulders above the other two.

This article is spot on.

absolutemoronwrote
Sun, 18 Nov 2012I hope the irony of dismissing a considered argument as one-sided in a brief and even more blinkered comment on a message board is not lost on you. You are right that this is a hugely complex issue, but you're missing the wider point being made here.

Nobody's saying that any producer has a divine right to earn a living from selling music. The point being made is that the increasingly widespread notion that recorded music should be free to the consumer feeds and accelerates a spiral of... More

MHBwrote
Sat, 17 Nov 2012Haven't live bands been doing the same thing since forever? Write songs, get in the studio and record, play live. Repeat.

I guess the argument would be that these guys aren't making a ton of money off of their recordings, but that's why they call it underground music. To make a killing off your recordings, then make the next 'Call On Me' or 'Levels' (easier said than done). If the music you release is esoteric RA-only approved bleeps, bloops and reverb then you're shit out of luck on... More

Make Mewrote
Fri, 16 Nov 2012This.

There are still people now who busy their asses with a full time job, and produce, run labels, and tear it up in the club. Work ethic and talent will always win out in the long run. Just look at peeps like jus-ed, Fred P, the deconstruct crew... All real people with real lives who do it all because they are driven to.

danielchasewrote
Fri, 16 Nov 2012The computer: best/worst thing that ever happened to music.

dazedetenwrote
Fri, 16 Nov 2012He doesn't say there isn't any interesting music being released - he says that the situation makes it harder to find among the proliferation of mediocre stuff being churned out. Which is essentially the exact same thing you're saying.







Maybe a different title would have worked better for the contents of the article. I don't entirely disagree with some of the views in the article, but when you say 'dance music is in creative crisis', its a broad brush and a fallacy, when there is... More


There are 13 other comments.
Click here to view the full thread


Newer feeds
Fri, 16 Nov 2012  /  RA
Got 26 minutes to kill? Familiarise yourself with breakthrough Belgian producer and Hotflush signee Locked Groove.

Fri, 16 Nov 2012  /  samlouis
This video interview with Audio Doughnuts finds the veteran house producer discussing his early days of making music and growing up in Detroit. More ›

Fri, 16 Nov 2012  /  gregsawyer
The Crosstown boss talks to Defected about his upcoming Mayan-inspired rave in Mexico and its accompanying compilation.


Older feeds
Fri, 16 Nov 2012  /  andrewryce
Kode9's frequent collaborator and vocalist has released a free solo EP inspired by his ongoing battle with Neurolymphamatosis, a rare form of cancer that's been affecting him for three years.

Thu, 15 Nov 2012  /  ryankeeling
Ron Morelli, head of the trailblazing NYC imprint, participates in RBMA's Fireside Chats series.

Thu, 15 Nov 2012  /  HerrJordan
The Diynamic producer recently collaborated with the Brandenburgishces Staatsorchester on a full orchestral version of "November Morning." This short doc posted to his YouTube channel shows it coming together. More ›


The Feed homepage

About  
Staff  
Mobile (beta)  
Submit event  
Copyright © 2013 Resident Advisor Ltd.
All rights reserved. Terms & Privacy.