RA
RA Japan
Global
Local
Music
Interact
Search RA

Forums


M.in, YNK & Bastian Schuster - New Orleans EP

Forum / Music
Replies (Views)  / 32 (2,060)
Notification / Send me email notification of replies
M.in, YNK & Bastian Schuster - New Orleans EP cover
RA Review
Don't be fooled by the monochromatic cover to M.in, YNK & Bastian Schuster's debut offering for OFF Recordings: These are four tracks full of color, each with something striking to say.


Posts /
60
RA Since /
Jul 2007

comooon !! this really deserves more than the poor 2.5 you gave... it's really fresh and good house music... M.in - Work That Body itself was one of the best track in your Resident Advisor hosted Josh Wink podcast so please coomoooon Dan !!


Posts /
53
RA Since /
Sep 2007

Agreed. This deserves more than a 2.5. It may not be the most groundbreaking release in the history of dance music, but the B-side shows massive potential for OFF. I think 'Goa' is especially warm and lovely (sounds insane on vinyl).


OUCH!


[ARP]
Posts /
772
RA Since /
Dec 2006

Work That Body sounds awesome on a huge system. Thank you Seth Troxler/Matthew Dear Fabric Room 2!


I like the B side, but agree with the reviewer. Here today, gone tomorrow. Though it applies to most of the records reviewed here.


Posts /
12
RA Since /
Feb 2009

thank you for that super review ... i think the support of all the biggest djs talks for this release so your review is not rightly!

you will hear much more from me in the next time ... i'm not here today and gone tomorrow cause my next release will be really strong!

i think the releases i have soon on get physical, get digital, kindisch, souvenir, micro.fon, merkesdir, will talk for me!

thx dan


... aus Liebe zur Musik!
Posts /
54
RA Since /
Oct 2008

yo what's that 2.5? there's only one word for this EP: brilliant! this piece of music deserves a lot more than a 2.5!!!!!! full support to M.in, Bastian Schuster and YNK! there's more and more ephemeral stuff than this one!


Posts /
2
RA Since /
Oct 2008

yeah! this is still a great release! work that body and new orleans (original) are really amazing tunes! will play them for a long time cause they kick me every time i play them... good work guys! keep it up!


Posts /
1
RA Since /
Dec 2008

yea!!! new orleans ....
AMAZING..


hey,

basically i'm always happy to have my label's music reviewed here also if it's a critical review.

but this is more than just critical, it's a ripoff which i cannot understand.

i know well that the jazz theme on new orleans is polarizing, but even if something is not your personal style, a review should always be objective.

and the facts are, this release has really classy samples and a great production, is insanely popular and gets played by all kinds of djs from the biggest names to the smallest bedroom dj's and even if one does not like the jazz sample theme, work that body is a timeless bomb that can be played for years to come.

nice to see the heated discussion here though! ;-)


Posts /
3
RA Since /
Dec 2008

I don't know exactly whether I should be offended or not?!
But at the end of the day full DJ support and a top10-position in German club charts chills me.
It's not everybody's cup of tea but as Andre said: This review is no critical comment - it's a ripoff.
Thank you, Resident Advisor DJ's for adjustment!


Posts /
1
RA Since /
Sep 2008

yeah, i dont think your review is good. For me this ep gives every house party a major peek moment. New Orleans is a really cool house looper and work that body reminds me on the easy slacky Sis - nesrib. So here we go. N O EP gets full support. and for next time, dont be soo critical, everythings just a subjective opinion but thats not pro. CYA


Posts /
1
RA Since /
Nov 2008

10 pops from 6 for this wonderfull ep! Perfekt work from my friend M.in and the others artists! Full support :-)


Posts /
4
RA Since /
Dec 2008

I totally don't agree the review,i think is a great EP,and it deserves lot more than this poor rating!!MORE VINYL LIKE THIS!!!!!!


http://www.frequenzarec.com facebook.com/alexdeliafreq youtube.com/frequenzarecords soundcloud.com/alexdelia
Posts /
1
RA Since /
Aug 2008

the pieces are wonderful...cant agree with the 2.5.....yes of course,everybody has his own opinion about the music...but...if you dont like it...ok...no problem....but pleeeaaase....before i can give a review like that i have to check the QUALITY....and the quality is fuckin amazin....no more words neccessary....


Posts /
35
RA Since /
Feb 2009

i dont agree with this review at all. New Orleans is an awesome track!


Posts /
2
RA Since /
Dec 2008

Love 'Work that Body'


Posts /
87
RA Since /
Aug 2007

'work that body' Realy good track for me..
2,5 is a bit hard..


Posts /
1
RA Since /
Jan 2009

Whaaaaat!!! M.in is on fire! I love this vibe... if you ask me its clever, fun booty shaking house music that puts a smile on my dial everytime!!! Need i say more..????


Posts /
1
RA Since /
Apr 2009

:O


Posts /
38
RA Since /
Feb 2009

One of the Best Ep's of 2009. Resident Advisor you are very very very wrong im afraid.


Posts /
11
RA Since /
Mar 2005

I wonder how Dan Hartman would feel if someone said the same thing about his qualities as a journalist/music reviewer...


www.thomasschumacher.com
Posts /
11
RA Since /
Mar 2005

as in: Here today, gone tomrrow...


www.thomasschumacher.com
Posts /
11
RA Since /
Mar 2005

DId I get the name wrong? Sorry.


www.thomasschumacher.com
Posts /
1
RA Since /
Apr 2009

here today, gone tomorow!? couldn't understand this review, becouse this record is hot for more than 2 month's now...it is still in the top sale charts on every onlinestor and in the german club charts also. you don't have to love this special kind of music, but you should be more objective as so many people said befor! as i imagine "minus" techno is also not for everyone...


Posts /
4
RA Since /
Apr 2009

you will hear some more tracks in this style...hope you will write a objective review like this for the others mr. Hartmann :D


Posts /
12
RA Since /
Feb 2009

if we reach 50 comments i spend some beers :)

i hope dan will write a better review at my next releases (soon) but "nobody likes the records that i play" so why he should like my tunes :) hehe


... aus Liebe zur Musik!
Posts /
187
RA Since /
Jun 2007

I think the score doesn't even reflect the review! defo worth more than 2.5!


http://www.hypercolour.co.uk http://sneakersocialclub.tumblr.com http://glasstablemusic.tumblr.com
that's what she said
Posts /
495
RA Since /
Oct 2007

whats with the harsh reviewing of the OFF releases?

4/5 from me, great stuff!


Posts /
8
RA Since /
Jun 2008

I've never even felt compelled to post on Resident Advisor before, but c'mon, this EP is hot shit. 2.5 and a largely scathing review? Hmm. Much better than all that.


Posts /
94
RA Since /
May 2008

i loved it and I love everything on this label - what I dont have I plan to buy


Posts /
12
RA Since /
Feb 2009

just want to say hallo again after some years :)
i want to thank you all for supporting so many of my tracks and brought me also many times into the top 50 of resident advisor and also into the top 100 charted artists of RA too.
i think i showed i was not here today and gone tomorrow :) i hope you all will like my upcoming album (release date in january 2012 on yellow tail)! Big thanks to ya all!


... aus Liebe zur Musik!

Reply
All times are GMT.   The time now is 06:36 AM on Mon, 20 May 2013.

Jump to forum /


About  
Staff  
Mobile (beta)  
Submit event  
Copyright © 2013 Resident Advisor Ltd.
All rights reserved. Terms & Privacy.