Scion presents Breaking Through - Submit an artist today
Buzzin Fly
RA: Resident Advisor Global
News
Features
The Feed
RA Newsletter
Local
Event listingsSubmit an event
Club Tickets
Party photos
Clubs bars and venues
Music
Music reviews
DJ PagesDJ Charts - Top 10s
Record labels
RA Podcast
Interact
My RA
Inbox
RA ForumsLatest forum topics
Competitions
Search RA

News


Aril Brikha accuses Shlomi Aber of plagiarism


The Swedish producer doesn't like the sound of Aber's 'Efrat.'
Words / Resident Advisor
Published / Thursday, 17 July 2008 06:54 AM
Category / Music News
Comments / 86 Comments



Aril Brikha has accused Israeli techno producer Shlomi Aber of plagiarism.

The famed Detroit devotee was reportedly e-mailed by a fan, pointing out the similarity between Aber's recent b-side 'Efrat' and his own 'Groove La Chord'. After comparing the two, Brikha took the matter to the court of public opinion and posted a long message to his blog on MySpace. After elucidating how close the songs were, including a unique off-beat chord that appears in both, Brikha then got a bit nasty:

"apparently, as so nicely written in his bio...not only has dance music chosen israel for its vacation. it has apparently also lost its integrity there."
Ouch. This is the internet, so it was only a matter of time before Aber showed up to the party in the comments, defending himself thusly:

"the sound may be a bit sounds on the same idea , but i guess he also used the same preset . I can say the same about million other tracks I found on the net which contains sounds From my tracks, which means , that if we using preset we don’t Owens them , if you check carefully you can find million other tracks Which used with the same preset, though non of them is tagged as "Shlomi Aber" and didn’t pull the fire in. I wonder what of the german producers wav will say about it , as they all use the same moog's bass and machines."

While we're still processing exactly what that means Brikha apparently ran it through Google Translator and was not impressed, responding:

"when it comes to these millions of tracks being THAT similar to groove la chord...im really curious on hearing them. as i mentioned before...i have NEVER made a statement like this to any other similar tracks...until now."

As of press time, the threat of legal action has been hinted at, but RA could not confirm that any suits had been filed.comment 86 Comments
 

Comments

Aril Brikha accuses Shlomi Aber of plagiarism

You're not logged in. You should register here to post your comments.

Anyone can register on RA - best of all it's free.
Fill in your details below to get started.

Email address /

RA username /
 

PastedFuturewrote
Wed, 21 Oct 2009The sound is not that similar. And the groove... come on! it's a classical groove! There must be thousands of tracks with that groove. Anyway I like Brikha much more. To me the only thievery to avoid is recognizable direct sampling and (complex enough) melody ripoff.

kevinreynoldswrote
Thu, 26 Feb 2009I know for a fact that Aril's was NOT a preset.

jonmcgillwrote
Mon, 05 Jan 2009Shlomi is a thief, come on people? this guy has no real history, a phony producer who is only ripping off classics and calling it his own, i cant think of anything more disgraceful. He should be banned from releasing music ever again, this wouldn't make a difference to me, I wouldn't buy a record of his in the first place nor do I own one. Aril's classic however, I have 3 copies of and wouldn't part with them even in the afterlife, Deeparture In Time on Transmat is a classic album which helped... More

EMitchellwrote
Mon, 15 Sep 2008Boom chick boom chick

All of it's the same anyway

defferwrote
Mon, 15 Sep 2008jungle brothers -I'll house you
royal house - can you party

didn't seem a prob back then.

danielpetrywrote
Sun, 14 Sep 2008Loads of tracks sound the same these days anyway it's a bit silly this. Everyone copies everyone else... maybe there should be some kind of Techno Complaints Bureau where everyone can submit complaints/insults/lawsuits whenever this happens??? I think it will be a busy bureau


There are 80 other comments.
Click here to view the full thread

News archive - select a period:
JanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDec
200120022003200420052006200720082009



July 2008 news

Tue, 1 Jul 2008
Mike Shannon plants The Memory Tree
Tom Wieland mixes Elaste Volume 02
Audioriver 2008 lineup announced
Circuit goes the distance
Kompakt prepares Total 9
^ Top  


Wed, 2 Jul 2008
Stefan Goldmann enters into a Transitory State
Jay Haze gives away album
Hernan Cattaneo makes his Pacha NYC debut
Ete D'Amour makes its home at Santos
Howells Digs RA at Ministry of Sound
Toby Tobias' Space Shuffle gets a capital launch
Sunday School For Degenerates comes to New York
^ Top  


Thu, 3 Jul 2008
Sasha gets involved again
Wild in the Country cancelled
Pacha NYC busted
Armin van Buuren plays McCarren Park
Pole counts to 3 once again
^ Top  


Fri, 4 Jul 2008
Mono_cult takes a dive
^ Top  


Mon, 7 Jul 2008
Nightmares on Wax go to Ibiza
The Märtini Brös mix themselves
The Herbaliser tours America
Gregor Tresher plays New York
Body & Soul returns to London
^ Top  


Tue, 8 Jul 2008
Charles Webster to spin for Future Classic
Sten distills his essence
Slam returns to T In The Park
^ Top  


Wed, 9 Jul 2008
The best thing about Hook N Sling
Slam become sci-fi fans
Dinky says it may be later
Hot Chip tours North America
^ Top  


Thu, 10 Jul 2008
Secretsundaze rules London
Berlin flaunts its Primary Colours
Mark Knight goes to the Toolroom
Airwaves announces first names
Jacopo Carreras moves from his bed to his couch
^ Top  


Fri, 11 Jul 2008
We Love... Resident Advisor
Spend the weekend with Dixon on the Adriatic
^ Top  


Mon, 14 Jul 2008
Classic goes digital
Betty Botox says Mmm...Betty
Andrew W.K. parties hard at Santos
Dapayk Solo enters the Devil's House
^ Top  


Tue, 15 Jul 2008
Dirt Crew compile Collection 02
Glade Festival announces finalised line-up
Bedrock hosts the South West Four afterparty
Deadly launches in London
Decibel's preliminary lineup announced
Huge Hephner debuts Nymphotech
^ Top  


Wed, 16 Jul 2008
Akufen visits Australia
Âme mixes Fabric 42
Riton plays a little night music
^ Top  


Thu, 17 Jul 2008
Aril Brikha accuses Shlomi Aber of plagiarism
^ Top  


Fri, 18 Jul 2008
Ladytron announce Australian tour
Craig Richards and the Nothing Special
Lovebox Weekender returns
Strut launches Inspiration Information
Kraftwerk play A Day In The Life
Rex The Dog welcomes you to the show
^ Top  


Sat, 19 Jul 2008
Party with RA at Eastern Electrics
^ Top  


Mon, 21 Jul 2008
Ladyhawke and Van She go Club Mod
Bloc launches their 2009 offensive
C/O Pop program announced
Mobilee plots their summer soiree
Mathew Jonson comes to Los Angeles
Lee Jones preps Electric Frank
M.A.N.D.Y and Tiefschwarz to play Minitek
^ Top  


Tue, 22 Jul 2008
Recloose to play HAHA
Global Underground enjoys the afterhours
Dirtybird comes to London
Final acts announced for Big Chill 2008
Ricardo, Danny and Diggers on the Black Sea
Los Updates comes to Cadenza
^ Top  


Wed, 23 Jul 2008
Mercury Prize nominees announced
DDD brings the concept of free to Ibiza
Stereo Nightclub Damaged in Fire, David Morales claims arson
Cut Copy and The Presets tour North America
^ Top  


Thu, 24 Jul 2008
Various Production remix and get remixed
Wolfgang Voigt premieres Gas, re-launches Profan
^ Top  


Fri, 25 Jul 2008
Homebake 2008 headliners announced
Pan/Tone skips the foreplay
N.A.M.E. Festival lineup announced
The Warehouse Project announces its 2008 lineup
M83 tour North America in November
^ Top  


Mon, 28 Jul 2008
Defected goes global at Ministry
Cocoon's Green & Blue returns to Frankfurt
Dubfunk mixes Audio Therapy Digital
Goldfrapp tours North America in September
^ Top  


Tue, 29 Jul 2008
CSS tours the UK
Octogen returns to Soma
Roisin Murphy, Stereo MCs headline Bloom
Steve Bug compiles Bugnology 3
Simon Baker tours the States and attends a picnic
SOS takes to the water
The Electronic Revolution according to Kraftwerk
^ Top  


Wed, 30 Jul 2008
Accelerating to Minnesota
Free Rotation lineup announced
Danny Tenaglia launches Futurism
Pivot asks you to soundtrack their heart
^ Top  


Thu, 31 Jul 2008
Earthdance Fundraiser at The Cross
Guy J debuts on Bedrock
David Holmes shows us The Holy Pictures
Monika Kruse changes perceptions
Dub Taylor revs up the Humatron
^ Top  









About  
RSS feeds  
Get involved  
Submit event  
Copyright © 2009 Resident Advisor Ltd.
All rights reserved. Terms & Privacy.