RA
RA Japan
Global
Local
Music
Interact
Search RA

Reviews


CNTRL: Beyond EDM in New York
Event / CNTRL: BEYOND EDM
Venue / Webster Hall/ New York, United States of America
Event date / Saturday, November 03, 2012
Line-up / RICHIE HAWTIN LOCO DICE tINI EAN GOLDEN - full details

Rating / 3.5

Whatever your opinion of Richie Hawtin, he is undeniably a star. After twenty-plus years of alternately exhilarating and head-scratching musical experiments, as well as recent forays into "authentic sake experiences" and underwater interviews with Carl Craig, the man still packs venues and inspires cacophonous shrieks from fans. CNTRL: Beyond EDM is Hawtin's latest brainchild, a bus tour of United States college towns intended, in Hawtin's own words, "to open up the definition of EDM" through a series of educational lectures and accompanying club nights.

The lecture portion of the CNTRL tour stop in New York City last Saturday was cancelled due to complications from Hurricane Sandy, but the show went on as planned at Webster Hall. It was a curiously commercial venue choice for a venture that, despite its best intentions, felt like it was preaching to the converted—or, at the very least, the blissfully ignorant and intoxicated.

Webster Hall is a historic New York venue, with a marquee that bathes the chaotic line outside in red. If Hawtin's futurism could speed up the coat-check line, it would be a welcome advancement: would-be revelers were stuck waiting as long as forty minutes, exposed to piledriver frequencies shuddering out of the downstairs dubstep dungeon while tINI chugged along playing house two floors up. tINI blitzed through grubby stacks of hiccuping percussion upended by whistling melodic accents, but the crowd was a swaying thrum of indifference, sweaty and impenetrable, many men shirtless and exuding aggression. The changeover to Loco Dice incited a rhythmic chant of "Loco, Loco," the Desolat head quickly washed away the comparatively dainty sounds of tINI. Switching between Ableton and Traktor, Dice slapped together brittle grooves with the irregular rhythms of disintegrating grandfather clocks, a trippy accompaniment as Daylight Savings Time sent the crowd time-traveling backwards

Playing from a laptop covered in Plastikman acid tab decals, Hawtin's set rode a wave of adulation through transitions that belched and crackled, with harrowing SETI signals and rollercoasters of bass. He moved through the springy loops and scattered thump of Daniel Avery's "One in the Wave" en route to choppier vocal incantations like Nitzer Ebb's "Join in the Chant," all while toying with a rubber chicken planted next to his computer. The pummeling was far removed from the subtractive techniques he's emphasized in the past, but perhaps the shortened set and atmosphere had him reformatting the expansive palette of European minimal to a more typically American dance floor attention span.

While the CNTRL tour on the whole attempts to penetrate the growing American college market for dance music, you have to think Hawtin recognizes the inherent limitations of his aesthetic for such an audience. (CNTRL has only a single location overlap with Tiësto's own behemoth college tour, an ostensible competitor for college ears.) For all the fanfare of presenting an alternate definition of "EDM," for many the night at Webster Hall seemed like just a welcome opportunity to party after a week of hurricane fallout. Walking downstairs to exit the venue, I passed more of the aforementioned shirtless hordes eager to join the swarm. One was saying to the other, "This guy named Richie Hawtin is playing upstairs. It's okay."



Published /
Fri, 09 November 2012


Webster Hall
 
Share this review

Comments

CNTRL: BEYOND EDM at Webster Hall

You're not logged in. You need to register to
post your comments.

Anyone can register on RA. Even you.

user-deletedwrote
Fri, 23 Nov 2012people in america today just don't wanna know.

let's keep it a 'us & them' thing, why should we say 'oh, look, there's more than EDM' to people who just want to kill our music (like those clowns on the RA roundtable months ago)?

littlecitybotwrote
Thu, 22 Nov 2012i reviewed the montreal edition of the CNTRL tour as well! you can check out discussion highlight, exclusive images and mooore right here! bit.ly/QcLfHs x

TheP00Pscoopwrote
Tue, 20 Nov 2012You can lead a horse to water, but you can't make it drink. I think most college kids are unfortunately content with David Guetta and Tiesto.

CarstenSwrote
Wed, 14 Nov 2012INDEED!

But if you wanted more that weeken, then 11/2 AND 11/3 b2b seemed a good idea, from the line-up.

And we get a repeat this weekend
Detmann followed by Liebing, with almost the same venue conundrum for many here, as it seems that WH and Pacha are about equally reviled.
BTW: the early Sund. morning Static looks pretty promising too!

survivorwrote
Wed, 14 Nov 2012JOHN DIGWEED IS BEYOND EDM - NO NEED TO HYPE THAT FACT LIKE HAWTIN DID HERE

survivorwrote
Wed, 14 Nov 2012The minuste I found out it was going to be at Webster Hall I already knew I wasnt going. Plus add the fact that John Digweed was playing the night before for Blk-Market and it was a no-brainer - the John Digweed Blk-Market party was what every real underground party should - a 5 houor journey into oblivion - whoever missed out on Digweed missed out on one of the better parties to have been held in NYC in a very long time, defineilty had that old school Twilo feel to it......


There are 144 other comments.
Click here to view the full thread

About  
Staff  
Mobile (beta)  
Submit event  
Copyright © 2013 Resident Advisor Ltd.
All rights reserved. Terms & Privacy.